Triad Adjustment, LLC.

Diminution or Diminished Value



"Diminution in Value or Diminished Value"


Virginia allows that, even after proper repairs have been made to your vehicle, you can recover the "loss of value" of your repaired vehicle in addition to the cost of the repairs.

Each state has its own Statute of Limitations regarding property damage. The Statute of Limitations requires a claim to be settled or lawsuit initiated within a 5 year period in Virginia after an accident has occurred. The Insurance companies and auto repair shops called this loss of value the "Diminution in Value" or "Diminished Value" of the vehicle.

In layman's terms,  "Diminution in Value" or "Diminished Value" means the difference in value between a vehicle that has never been damaged and the same vehicle after it has been damaged but has been properly repaired. Most of the time there is no significance difference but sometimes there is a tremendous difference. For instance, if you purchased a $50,000.00 Mercedes and someone ran into you causing a significant amount of exterior and inner structure damage, then even if you had someone make excellent repairs, the car would still not be worth what an undamaged one would cost.

Given the choice of purchasing a car that had never been damaged or purchasing a car that had been in a significant accident, most people would prefer the one that had never been damaged. How much is that difference worth? In determining whether there is any diminished value and, if so, what the amount of the diminished value is, many factors are considered. Important factors include the extent and nature of the damage to the vehicle; the cost of the repairs; the age of the vehicle; mileage and whether the car is of special interest including limited editions, collector's cars, or if other special circumstances exist.

There are three types of diminished value that every consumer should investigate after an accident;

Inherent Diminished Value - This is the type of Diminished Value most common in all insurance settlements where the car has been repaired. It assumes a high quality of repair has been achieved and is defined as the amount by which the resale value of a repaired vehicle has been reduced solely as a consequence of the vehicle now having a significant damage history.

Repair Related Diminished Value - Repair Related Diminished Value can be considered as a claim in addition to Inherent Diminished Value. It is generally described as the amount by which the resale value has been reduced as a consequence of less than optimal repairs. For example, the door sill was straightened/ realigned during repair but some rippling of the metal is still apparent. Such a repair may be functional, but falls short of the aesthetic condition of the original vehicle.

Immediate Diminished Value - This is defined as the difference in market value of a vehicle immediately before the accident occurred and immediately after. That is, before any repair work has been conducted on the vehicle.
Diminished value claims can only be made in certain situations.

There are two types of motor vehicle property damage claims under motor vehicle insurance;

The first is a "first party" claim where you make a claim against your own insurance company under your collision coverage. These claims are made when you or someone driving you vehicle is at fault.

The second type of claim is a "liability claim", when you are making a claim against someone else's insurance because they are at fault.

Diminished value claims in Virginia only apply to liability claims or 3rd party claims, when the vehicle damage was caused by someone else's negligence, and not to first party "collision" claims, when the damage results from the owner's fault or someone the owner allows to drive the vehicle.

Most insurance carriers doing business in Virginia are aware of "Diminution in Value" or "Diminished Value" claims and regularly negotiate these claims when presented by the party whose auto has been extensively damaged by the negligence of the carrier's insured (usually their policyholder). Keep in mind the insurance company normally will not voluntarily solicit a diminished value claim but, when confronted with the proper documentation, they will consider it.

Proper documentation includes:

1. Photographs of the initial damages and supplemental damages if applicable.
2. Photographs after the repairs were completed.
3. Written appraisal, after repairs, documenting the condition of the vehicle and "loss of value" (this is the difference in market value prior to accident and after repairs to vehicle), by a qualified appraiser.

Although the appraiser will assign a specific dollar amount to the diminished value, the majority of insurance companies conducting business in the state of Virginia will want to negotiate. To be in the best bargaining position, you should get an appraiser who has the best credentials to appraise the diminished value for your specific vehicle, as that person will have the most credibility with the insurance company.

In Virginia, liability coverage of an automobile insurance policy states that the insurance company will pay for all of the damage that its insured is legally obligated to pay. Insurers in Virginia typically consider each claim on its own merits and pay diminished value when the investigation warrants payment.

However, Virginia law is silent regarding the issue of "Diminution in Value or Diminished Value", and there is no method prescribed by law to determine the vehicle's diminished value. There is no set formula or calculation method in place that can determine the correct diminished value of your vehicle after the vehicle has been repaired. The insurer should consider any credible evidence of diminished value before determining whether or not it is owed on a particular claim.

Triad Adjustment, LLC can help with the process and help you try to recover some financial reimbursement for you loss. Please be aware that this is a negotiation process only, not a guarantee, that the insurance company will pay but this is an option in Virginia that you are entitled to pursue.

Please contact us

Triad Adjustment, LLC

Enter supporting content here